Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Depressing determinism

Got to hand it to Jennifer Byrne( Bookclub intro this week ) - her honesty is refreshing .
Why? The mood is one of , if not paranoia , depression? Someone has to say it - "we're stuck !" Depression is hard to admit, but if you are in a cul de sac , maybe just maybe , there is a way out ! Logically though , you have to acknowledge what signposts you were ignoring on the way in !!!

Like Emperor Julian , there are always those who think Plato and the old Greeks knew it all . "That those Christians are rejecting the rational in favour of .???? the truly unbelievable " .....some other time! Like a broken record -----prove what ? I do not care to prove everything !

The point is ---Its not very exciting for those of us who enjoy our daily speculation beyond the material, to see the Julian type Emperors at ABCchurch still thousands of years later grieving for a system of thinking that is not scientific but stultifying, circular and clearly stuck in the earths' own mud.
As One old Roman convert of the time put it when he started reading into the signposts - you know - point TO counterpoint is OK , even for a scientist, but its tiring and its not everything ---there is a great enjoyable space beyond such things !)

1 comment:

journeymanj said...

One week on, the mood is just as circular; and the search for truth stiffled - were the girls more interested in the boy ? ;even more than what was being said ?
Whatever - a nice talk fest by members who would rather be nasty than nice ( devil celebration element ) symbolicly led by jennifers preoccupation with chorus of joy over volume and that desperately seeking deterministic excuse for reading the boring books they seem happy to testify from.